top of page

EI & Severance Double-Dip Rule - Zero Clawback Until 2027

Writer: Tony Wong
Tony Wong
29 minutes ago
14 min read
Employment lawyers advising a client on Canada's no-clawback EI and severance rules


Key Legal Takeaway (Updated November 2026): Under federal Employment Insurance Pilot Project No. 25 (SOR/2026-203), in effect from October 11, 2026 through October 9, 2027, Service Canada has waived the one-week EI waiting period and suspended all severance and vacation-pay clawbacks. Terminated and constructively dismissed employees in Ontario and federally regulated workplaces can collect full weekly EI benefits (up to $729/week in 2026; $749/week for claims starting December 27, 2026+) immediately while keeping 100% of their lump-sum severance settlement or court judgment—provided they apply within 4 weeks and avoid the payroll salary-continuance trap.


Can you collect Employment Insurance (EI) and severance pay at the same time without a clawback? Yes. Until October 9, 2027, Canadian workers who lose their jobs—or are forced out through constructive dismissal—can legally collect full EI regular benefits from Week 1 and pocket every dollar of a wrongful dismissal severance package with zero Service Canada delay or overpayment clawback.


For nearly fifty years, Canadian employment law barred this kind of concurrent recovery. Civil courts refused to deduct EI benefits from wrongful dismissal damages under Jack Cewe Ltd. v. Jorgenson, 1980 CanLII 177 (SCC), [1980] 1 S.C.R. 812 (at p. 818)—a rule reaffirmed by the Supreme Court of Canada in IBM Canada Limited v. Waterman, 2013 SCC 70 (CanLII), [2013] 3 S.C.R. 985 (at paras. 44, 51) and applied in Ontario in Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402 (CanLII) (at para. 103). Instead, sections 45 and 46 of the Employment Insurance Act, S.C. 1996, c. 23, required settling employers and dismissed workers to repay overlapping EI benefits to the Receiver General out of the eventual severance settlement.


By extending Pilot Project No. 24 (SOR/2025-115 and SOR/2026-64, which covered March 30, 2025 to October 10, 2026) into Pilot Project No. 25 (SOR/2026-203) from October 11, 2026 through October 9, 2027, Ottawa temporarily switched off Service Canada's severance clawback while leaving Jack Cewe untouched. Yet thousands of unrepresented employees still lose $15,000 to $35,000+ in combined recovery by waiting too long to apply, signing the wrong payment structure, or resigning quietly without a legal paper trail. Below is the exact legal playbook to claim every dollar on the table before this window closes.


Table of Content:


1. What Changed Under Pilot Project No. 25 (SOR/2026-203)—and When It Ends



Normally, sections 35 and 36 of the Employment Insurance Regulations, SOR/96-332, treat severance pay, pay in lieu of notice, and termination vacation payouts as "earnings," allocating them forward week-by-week from your layoff date to delay your EI start date or trigger an overpayment bill.


Under SOR/2026-203 (adding ss. 77.9991–77.9995 to the EI Regulations effective October 11, 2026), four pro-worker rules govern EI claims across Canada:


  • Zero Severance Delay or Clawback (Until October 9, 2027 — s. 77.9993): Lump-sum monies paid or payable by reason of a layoff or separation—statutory termination and severance pay, common-law wrongful dismissal settlements or court judgments, vacation pay paid upon termination, closure/loyalty bonuses, and accumulated sick-leave payouts—do not constitute "earnings" under s. 35(2) and trigger zero EI allocation.


  • No One-Week Unpaid Waiting Period (Until October 9, 2027 — s. 77.9992): The standard one-week EI deductible (EI Act, s. 13) is waived for all benefit periods beginning between October 11, 2026 and October 9, 2027, so EI pays from Week 1. (Narrow SUB Plan Exception: If your employer maintains a registered Supplemental Unemployment Benefit [SUB] plan whose top-up specifically requires serving a waiting week, Service Canada permits serving that week where doing so increases your total payout.)


  • Only Your Most Recent Separation Counts (October 11, 2026 – October 9, 2027 — s. 77.9995): Ordinarily, quitting an earlier job without just cause wipes out all insurable hours banked before that quit (EI Act, s. 30(1), (5)–(7)). Under s. 77.9995, Service Canada adapts ss. 29(a) and 30 so that as long as your most recent job separation was through no fault of your own, all insurable hours and earnings from prior jobs inside your qualifying period count toward EI eligibility, duration, and benefit rates.


  • 20 Extra Weeks of EI for Long-Tenured Workers (Early Deadline: June 12, 2027 — s. 77.9994): Workers who paid at least 30% of the maximum annual employee EI premium in at least 7 of the last 10 tax years and were paid fewer than 36 weeks of regular EI benefits in the preceding 156 weeks (3 years) receive 20 extra weeks of regular EI (lifting the maximum cap from 45 weeks to 65 weeks). Note the earlier June 12, 2027 cutoff—tribunals strictly enforce pilot-project start and end dates without equitable or fairness exceptions.


  • 2026 vs. 2027 Maximum Weekly EI Rates: In 2026, Maximum Yearly Insurable Earnings (MIE) are $68,900, yielding up to $729/week. Effective January 1, 2027, the MIE rises to $70,800, and for EI claims starting on or after December 27, 2026, the maximum weekly benefit rises to $749/week.


2. Scenario A: Claiming EI Right Now and Winning a Severance Settlement or Judgment Later



Suppose you are fired without cause today. Your employer hands you a lowball severance offer with a 72-hour deadline. Instead of signing away your rights, you apply for EI immediately and hire an employment lawyer to pursue full wrongful dismissal damages. Months later, you settle or win at trial. Does Service Canada claw back your EI?


Your Dismissal & Settlement Timeline

Service Canada Severance Clawback?

Legal Authority (EI Regulations & EI Act)

Fired & Claim EI Now → Settle or Win Judgment BEFORE Oct. 9, 2027

$0 Clawback (100% Exempt)

Both your EI benefit period start and separation week fall inside s. 77.9993 (SOR/2026-203). Zero s. 45 overpayment; zero s. 46 employer holdback.

Fired & Claim EI Inside Pilot Windows (Mar. 30, 2025 – Oct. 9, 2027) → Lawsuit Settles in 2028+

$0 Clawback (100% Exempt)

Disjunctive ("or") text of s. 77.997(a)–(b) (Mar. 30, 2025 – Oct. 10, 2026) and s. 77.9993(a)–(b) (Oct. 11, 2026 – Oct. 9, 2027) tests your benefit period start OR first week of allocation under ss. 36(9)–(11)—never the date your settlement cheque clears.

Fired BEFORE Mar. 30, 2025 → Old Lawsuit Settles in 2026 or 2027

Full Clawback Applies

Allocation reverts to your pre-March 30, 2025 separation week under s. 36(9) (unless your EI benefit period itself began on or after Mar. 30, 2025); standard ss. 45–46 repayment rules apply.


Three Critical Traps That Can Still Cost You Money in Scenario A


  1. Refuse Payroll "Salary Continuance"—Insist on a Lump Sum: Under section 14(1) of the EI Regulations, you cannot open an EI claim without a 7-day "interruption of earnings." Under CRA Income Tax Folio S2-F1-C2 (Retiring Allowances) and ESDC policy, payroll salary continuance keeps you on active insurable payroll rather than paying separation severance. Accept 10 months of salary continuance in January 2027, and your interruption of earnings won't occur until November 2027—after the October 9, 2027 waiver expires—destroying your double recovery. Structure settlements as lump-sum retiring allowances, not active payroll continuance.


  2. Report Every Dollar to Service Canada (And Watch Side-Hustle Rules): Pilot Project No. 25 waives deductions, not disclosure. Hiding a severance payout breaches EI Act s. 50 and triggers s. 38(1) misrepresentation penalties and 72-month audits under s. 52(5)—even when declaring it accurately produces a $0 deduction. Also remember that new employment wages, freelance work, or gig income earned while on EI still face the Working While on Claim deduction (50 cents per dollar earned up to 90% of weekly insurable earnings, and dollar-for-dollar above 90%).


  3. Beware the Separate CRA 30% Tax-Return Clawback (EI Act, s. 145): Service Canada's severance waiver does not pause the Canada Revenue Agency's high-income tax-return EI repayment. Under EI Act s. 145(1), if your annual net income on your T1 tax return exceeds 1.25 x MIE ($86,125 in 2026; $88,500 in 2027), you must repay up to 30% of your regular EI benefits at tax time.


  • Who Is 100% Exempt (EI Act, s. 145(2)): If you collected less than 1 week of regular or fishing EI in the preceding 10 tax years, your CRA repayment is $0—even on a $300,000 severance package. (EI Sickness, Maternity, Parental, and Caregiving special benefits are also 100% exempt under s. 145(1)(a).)


  • How Repeat Claimants Shelter Their Payout: If you collected regular EI in the last decade, employment counsel can reduce net income below $86,125 / $88,500 via direct RRSP contributions or transfers (T4 Retiring Allowance Codes 66/67 where eligible), multi-year retiring-allowance instalments split across December and January, deductible legal fee allocations (Income Tax Act, s. 60(o.1)), or genuine non-taxable human rights / harassment general damages (CRA Folio S2-F1-C2, ¶2.17).


3. Scenario B: The Delayed-Application Trap (Settling First, Applying for EI Later)



What if you hold off on applying for EI while your lawyer negotiates, sign a severance settlement in mid-2027, and then apply for EI? While s. 77.9993 still stops the settlement cash from pausing future EI payments (if you apply on or before October 9, 2027), delaying your EI application is a costly mistake:


1. You Permanently Lose Retroactive EI Weeks (Strict "Antedate" Rules): If you miss the 4-week administrative filing window from your last day of work, Service Canada will not backdate ("antedate") your claim under EI Act s. 10(4) unless you prove continuous "good cause" across every single week of delay. The Federal Court of Appeal rejects virtually every common excuse:


  • Good-faith ignorance of the law or the pilot rules is not good cause (Canada (Attorney General) v. Kaler, 2011 FCA 266 (CanLII), at paras. 4, 8; Canada (Attorney General) v. Somwaru, 2010 FCA 336 (CanLII)).


  • Claimants bear an affirmative duty to take prompt steps to verify their EI rights and obligations (Canada (Attorney General) v. Carry, 2005 FCA 367 (CanLII); Canada (Attorney General) v. Innes, 2010 FCA 341 (CanLII); Quadir v. Canada (Attorney General), 2018 FCA 21 (CanLII)).


  • Living off savings/severance, focusing on job hunting, or waiting on a late ROE fails the test (Howard v. Canada (Attorney General), 2011 FCA 116 (CanLII); narrow exceptions generally require direct official or employer misinformation where a reasonable person would have been misled, as in Canada (Attorney General) v. Albrecht, 1985 CanLII 5582 (FCA), [1985] 1 F.C. 710 (C.A.)).


  • Because separation pay is no longer allocated across post-termination weeks under s. 77.9993, you also lose the normal qualifying-period and benefit-period extension buffers under EI Act ss. 8(2)(c) and 10(10)(b).


2. Your 52-Week Qualifying Hours Bleed Away: Under EI Act s. 8(1), Service Canada counts insurable hours strictly inside the 52 weeks right before your claim starts (Remaining Hours = (52 - weeks delayed) x weekly hours). A part-time worker (20 hrs/wk) drops below a 700-hour regional threshold after just 18 weeks (~4 months) of delay and below 420 hours after Week 31; even a full-time worker (40 hrs/wk) drops below 700 hours at Week 35 and is completely disqualified (<420 hours) at Week 42.


4. Constructive Dismissal ("Forced to Quit"): How a Demand Letter Protects Both EI and Severance



If an employer slashes your pay, demotes you, piles on unpaid excessive overtime, tolerates harassment, or pressures you to resign, leaving is constructive dismissal—legally treated as a termination without cause rather than a voluntary quit:


  • Full Severance Under Ontario & Common Law: Under Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), S.O. 2000, c. 41, ss. 56(1)(b) and 63(1)(b), and the Supreme Court of Canada's two-branch test in Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10 (CanLII), [2015] 1 S.C.R. 500 (at paras. 30–33, 37–43, 46; building on Farber v. Royal Trust Co., 1997 CanLII 387 (SCC), [1997] 1 S.C.R. 846, and applied in Brake, 2017 ONCA 402 (CanLII), at paras. 63–65), either a single substantial unilateral breach of essential terms or a toxic cumulative course of conduct entitles you to full statutory and common-law severance.


  • Full EI Under EI Act s. 29(c): While voluntarily quitting without cause disqualifies you (Canada (Attorney General) v. Peace, 2004 FCA 56 (CanLII), at paras. 15–16), section 29(c) preserves full EI where, having regard to all the circumstances, you had "no reasonable alternative to leaving" (Canada (Attorney General) v. White, 2011 FCA 190 (CanLII), at paras. 3–4; Canada (Attorney General) v. Imran, 2008 FCA 17 (CanLII); Canada (Attorney General) v. Laughland, 2003 FCA 129 (CanLII)). Covered statutory grounds include workplace harassment (s. 29(c)(i)), significant pay modifications (s. 29(c)(vii)), excessive overtime or refusal to pay overtime (s. 29(c)(viii)), significant changes in work duties (s. 29(c)(ix)), supervisor antagonism (s. 29(c)(x)), and undue employer pressure to leave (s. 29(c)(xiii)).


  • Why You Must Never Walk Out Silently: Under White, employees who resign out of the blue and receive a Code E (Quit) ROE routinely lose EI because they cannot show they gave the employer a chance to cure the breach—and Service Canada is not automatically bound even if an employer later amends the ROE to Code A (Shortage of Work) without underlying documentation. Having an employment lawyer serve a formal written demand letter before or upon exit defeats civil condonation under Potter, hands Service Canada the exact contemporaneous written record needed to approve EI under s. 29(c), and builds maximum leverage for full severance plus a clean ROE.


5. EI Time Limits & Eligibility Rules: Who Can (and Cannot) Claim EI



Apply online within 4 calendar weeks of your last day worked—never wait for your employer's ROE (due electronically within 5 calendar days after the end of the pay period in which your interruption of earnings occurs under EI Regulations s. 19(3.1)), and file your bi-weekly claimant reports on time (EI Act, s. 10(5); Paxton v. Canada (Attorney General), 2002 FCA 360 (CanLII), at para. 11).

Who QUALIFIES for Regular EI

Who DOES NOT Qualify for Regular EI

1. Employees (EI Act, s. 5(1)(a)): Full-time, part-time, or misclassified "independent contractors" who are truly employees under 671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries Canada Inc., 2001 SCC 59 (CanLII). (Request a CRA Form CPT1 insurable-employment ruling by June 29 of the following calendar year.)

1. Genuine Contractors & >40% Shareholders: True self-employed contractors (even if opted into EI special benefits) and corporate owners controlling more than 40% of voting shares (EI Act, s. 5(2)(b)).

2. 420–700 Insurable Hours (EI Act, s. 7): Accumulated during the 52-week qualifying period based on your regional unemployment rate (including prior-job hours protected under s. 77.9995).

2. Under the Hours Floor: Fewer than 420 insurable hours in the 52-week lookback (or higher hours required due to prior s. 7.1 misrepresentation violations).

3. Fired Without "Wilful Misconduct" (Or Constructively Dismissed): Layoffs, restructuring, poor performance, missed sales targets, or "bad fit" all qualify! Disqualifying misconduct requires conscious, deliberate, or reckless wrongdoing (Canada (Attorney General) v. Tucker, 1986 CanLII 6794 (FCA), [1986] 2 F.C. 329; Mishibinijima v. Canada (Attorney General), 2007 FCA 36 (CanLII), at para. 14; Canada (Attorney General) v. Hastings, 2007 FCA 372 (CanLII); Canada (Attorney General) v. Brissette, 1993 CanLII 3020 (FCA), [1994] 1 F.C. 684).

3. True Wilful Misconduct or Personal Quit (EI Act, s. 30): Proven theft, workplace violence, deliberate insubordination, or resigning for personal reasons without s. 29(c) just cause.

4. Capable & Available for Work (EI Act, s. 18(1)(a)): Physically and mentally able to work, inside Canada, legally authorized to work, and maintaining a daily job-search log.

4. Unavailable, Expired/Closed Permits, or Medically Unable: Outside Canada, on strike/lockout, holding an expired SIN or employer-specific closed work permit without authorization to work elsewhere, or medically unable to work (claim 26-week EI Sickness Benefits [600 hrs; 0% CRA s. 145 tax clawback] first, then convert to Regular EI once medically cleared).


6. Ontario (ESA) Workers vs. Federally Regulated (Canada Labour Code) Workers


While EI rules apply identically across Canada, substantive severance rights and filing deadlines differ sharply between Ontario provincially regulated industries (~90% of workers) and federally regulated sectors (~10%: banks, telecoms, airlines, rail, interprovincial trucking, broadcasting, and federal Crown corporations):


Legal Dimension

Ontario Provincially Regulated (ESA & Common Law)

Federally Regulated (Canada Labour Code Part III)

EI Waiver & Oct. 9, 2027 Sunset

100% Identical (EI Act & SOR/2026-203).

100% Identical (EI Act & SOR/2026-203).

Statutory Minimum Floor

Up to 8 weeks' termination notice/pay (ESA, s. 57) + up to 26 weeks' statutory severance pay (5+ yrs' service & $2.5M+ payroll, s. 64) + Common-Law reasonable notice.

2–8 weeks' graduated individual notice (CLC, s. 230(1.1)) + 2 days/yr statutory severance (min. 5 days after 12 mos., s. 235) + Common-Law notice or Unjust Dismissal remedies.

Without-Cause Firing Allowed?

Yes, provided full statutory and common-law severance is paid (and no human rights or reprisal breach occurred).

NO for non-union, non-managerial employees with 12+ consecutive months of service (absent genuine lack of work or discontinuance of a function)! Protected against Unjust Dismissal (CLC, s. 240; Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., 2016 SCC 29 (CanLII), [2016] 1 S.C.R. 770, at paras. 44, 63–64).

Limitation / Filing Deadlines

2 years for civil wrongful or constructive dismissal lawsuits (Limitations Act, 2002, s. 4).

STRICT 90 DAYS to file a CLC s. 240 Unjust Dismissal complaint (CLC, s. 240(2))—or 2 years for a civil wrongful dismissal lawsuit.


Critical Federal Reinstatement Warning: If the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) reinstates a federal worker with retroactive back pay under CLC s. 240, the employment relationship is restored unbroken—meaning retroactive wages are active employment income rather than separation pay under s. 77.9993, triggering a full ss. 45–46 EI clawback. Conversely, filing within 90 days to preserve reinstatement leverage and negotiating a lump-sum financial settlement that permanently ends employment gives you double legal protection: statutory exemption under s. 77.9993 inside the pilot window, plus permanent Federal Court of Appeal protection exempting genuine consideration paid to relinquish a statutory right to reinstatement from s. 35(2) earnings (Canada v. Plasse, 2000 CanLII 16290 (FCA); Meechan v. Canada (Attorney General), 2003 FCA 368 (CanLII); Bourgeois v. Canada (Attorney General), 2004 FCA 117 (CanLII); Canada (Attorney General) v. Cantin, 2008 FCA 192 (CanLII); Canada (Attorney General) v. Boucher-Dancause, 2010 FCA 270 (CanLII)).


7. Frequently Asked Questions (EI & Severance Clawback Rules 2026–2027)


Does severance pay delay EI in Ontario in 2026 and 2027?


No. Under Employment Insurance Pilot Project No. 25 (SOR/2026-203), in effect through October 9, 2027, lump-sum severance pay, pay in lieu of notice, and termination vacation payouts do not delay your EI start date or reduce your weekly EI cheques.


If my wrongful dismissal lawsuit settles after October 9, 2027, will Service Canada claw back my EI?


No—provided your job loss (first week of normal allocation under ss. 36(9)–(11)) or EI benefit period began between March 30, 2025 and October 9, 2027. Sections 77.997 and 77.9993 test when your claim or separation began, not the year your settlement or court judgment is paid.


Should I wait until my severance package is settled before applying for EI?


Never. You must apply for EI within 4 weeks of your last day worked (even if your employer has not yet issued your ROE). Waiting to settle forfeits retroactive weeks of EI (Kaler, 2011 FCA 266 (CanLII)) and erodes the 52-week insurable-hours window needed to qualify.


Can I get EI and severance if I quit a toxic workplace or after a pay cut?


Yes, if your resignation qualifies as constructive dismissal. Having an employment lawyer serve a formal written demand letter before or upon leaving documents "just cause" and "no reasonable alternative" for Service Canada under EI Act s. 29(c) while preserving your full statutory and common-law severance claim.


Summary Cheat Sheet: Here is everything you need to know to collect 100% of your lump-sum severance and full EI benefits with zero Service Canada clawback before the October 9, 2027 federal waiver (SOR/2026-203) expires:   

Infographic summarizing Canada's EI and severance clawback waiver under SOR/2026-203 in effect until October 9, 2027

8. Protect Your EI and Maximize Your Severance Before Signing Anything


The federal window allowing dismissed employees to keep 100% of their lump-sum severance settlement alongside full weekly EI benefits runs strictly until October 9, 2027. Once you sign an employer's release—or resign quietly without putting formal legal objections on the record—you can forfeit tens of thousands of dollars in wrongful dismissal damages and jeopardize your Employment Insurance eligibility.


Before signing a termination offer, accepting payroll salary continuance, or walking out of a toxic or altered role, have experienced employment legal counsel review your severance entitlements, structure your payout as a tax-efficient lump sum, and protect your EI record from Day 1.


For a quick summary of the upcoming maximum weekly benefit rate increase taking effect on December 27, 2026, watch Employment Insurance Benefits Increasing up to $749 per Week in 2027, which highlights how the new $749 weekly cap applies to eligible EI claims starting late December 2026 into 2027.


For deeper legal breakdowns on Ontario and federal workplace rights, explore our Employment Law Blog, Video Library, and the Employment Law Insights Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.



Don't fight in the dark. Contact the experienced employment lawyers at HTW Law today to protect your rights, your reputation, and your bottom line.

With the right legal support, employees can ensure their employment law rights are protected; employers can avoid lawsuits. 

top law firm with best employment lawyers in toronto

Relevant Blog Posts:




HTW Law - top employment law firm 2023

As an employee, you don't have to fight the battle alone. Speaking with an employment lawyer who is familiar with the laws and regulations regarding defamation, discrimination, harassment, wrongful termination, and constructive dismissal, employment contracts and employment law in general will go a long way. If you are in doubt, it's essential that you reach out for help as soon as possible right away.

Click here to contact HTW Law - Employment Lawyer for assistance and legal consultation.


contact htw law - employment lawyer for wrongful dismissal help

Author bio:


Tony Wong, B.Sc. (Hons.), J.D. / LL.B., is an Ontario employment lawyer (licensed by the Law Society of Ontario) and Founder of HTW Law Professional Corporation in Toronto. He represents Ontario and federally regulated employees and employers in wrongful dismissal, constructive dismissal, severance, and human rights disputes in Canada and aboard. His work has been recognized by USA Today, MSN, and Manage HR. 





bottom of page